Printable View
I don't know who put together the RB 3 Playlist but just C&Pasting the charts from other playlists doesnt cut it and can lead to disasters on stage. I found 2 arrangements on this forum and neither was the one that the RB 3 uses or the Grantham Blue Gig Book .
I make no judgments on the chords but these are the ones in the RB3
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams RB3 - Harry Barris
Thanks for starting the song discussion thread for this tune.
:))BOB
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams - Harry Barris
Another take on this tune. This tune can be re-harmed ad nauseum!
Thanks, Bobsax.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobsax
I think the F7 in the second A section is wrong, as the melody is on E natural. It should be G7, as in the first A, no?
Cheers,
Jer
F Maj 7 for the melody and F7 or F13+11 for the solos. That's the way we play the tune.
You are right Jeri ,Oddly the version I did doesn't have the F . I don't know how it got there . I'm pretty sure the F is in the original IRP version so somebody out there likes it.Quote:
Originally Posted by engelbach
here is the correct chart . Perhaps a mod can fix ? Sorry
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams RB3 - Harry Barris
Bobsax,
If it is your intention to post an accurate transcription of the RB3 changes, please specify which of the two charts you've posted labeled "RB3" is correct as the voicings are quite different. (and I'm not referring to Jer's suggested correction)
When there's agreement that you've provided an accurate RB3 chart, I'll correct your post which I copied to the RB3 thread.
:))BOB
Sorry the one titled RB3 1 with the F in the last A section is a mistake Hopefully it can be purged
The one I just posted should have that F7 removed .Quote:
Originally Posted by pdxdjazz
raymb1,Quote:
Originally Posted by raymb1
That's fine, but the chart then would need to have separate sections for the head and the solos.
Although I don't care for the FMaj7 sound on the head.
Cheers,
Jer
Read my post again....it's NOT about that erroneous F7. (None of your posted charts are labeled RB3 1)Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobsax
:))BOB
I don't understand what your asking Bob.?Quote:
Originally Posted by pdxdjazz
Here is the Dixieland version from the Dixie thread.
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams (Dixieland Tunes) - Harry Barris, Ted Koehler, Billy Moll (1931)
I did not do this one
I think at this point There should be
1) the original from IRB which BTW is nothing like the original song.
2) The corrected RB3
3 The Dixie I just posted here
When this gets sorted out I will post the one my piano player used back in the 60's that has a coda
You posted both these charts in this thread
Which (if either) is the correct RB3 transcription?
Different Voicings (2)
Individual songs:
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams RB3 - Harry Barris
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams RB3 - Harry Barris
I would just use the Alt chord above and put a note with the text tool to be played on "head only"Quote:
Originally Posted by engelbach
Oh you mean the alt chords?Quote:
Originally Posted by pdxdjazz
I took them out
This should be the final corrected chart. I put an * to differentiate it.
If possible Bob, can purge the wrong charts and remove all this unnecessary threads relating to it?
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams RB3* - Harry Barris
I updated your chart in the RB 3 thread
http://www.irealb.com/forums/showthr...-Book-III-list
No, I was referring to the different voicings of the player-chords.Quote:
Originally Posted by Bobsax
I think the discussion here stands on its own.
:))BOB
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams (4)
Individual songs:
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams - Harry Barris
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams (Alan) - Harry Barris
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams (Dixieland Tunes) - Harry Barris, Ted Koehler, Billy Moll (1931)
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams RB3* - Harry Barris
Wrap Your Troubles In Dreams - Harry Barris